The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), born from a simple agreement between 24 brokers and merchants in 1792, has been the stage for immense wealth creation and devastating losses. Countless individuals have sought to tap into the stock market’s potential, aiming to build their financial futures. But amidst the volatility and complexity, how can the average investor navigate the stock exchange to truly earn money? This guide, crafted by money-central.com’s financial experts, delves into the essential strategies and principles for making money in the stock exchange, designed to surpass the depth and SEO effectiveness of typical online financial content.
Key Strategies for Stock Market Success
- Long-Term Buy-and-Hold Investing: For most individual investors, a buy-and-hold approach in equities presents the most reliable path to wealth accumulation.
- Historical Stock Market Performance: Studies, such as the 2011 Raymond James and Associates analysis (1926-2010), highlight the superior returns of small-cap stocks (12.1% annually) and large-cap stocks (9.9% annually) compared to government bonds and inflation.
- Understanding Investment Risks: Equity investments carry two primary risk types: systematic risk (macroeconomic events like recessions) and unsystematic risk (company or industry-specific issues).
- Risk Mitigation through Diversification: Many investors reduce unsystematic risk by investing in diversified instruments like exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or mutual funds instead of individual stocks.
- Avoiding Common Investor Pitfalls: Key mistakes include poor asset allocation, attempting to time the market, and emotional investing.
Understanding the Stock Market Basics
Stocks, or equities, represent ownership shares in publicly traded companies listed on stock exchanges. For any investor aiming to build a robust portfolio, stocks are a critical component. The allocation of stocks within your portfolio—including the proportion, industry sectors, and holding duration—should be tailored to your individual circumstances, including age, risk tolerance, and overarching investment objectives.
Financial professionals, including discount brokers and advisors, often present compelling statistics illustrating the historical outperformance of stocks over extended periods. However, it’s crucial to recognize that not all stocks are created equal. Selecting poorly performing stocks can erode wealth and prevent investors from capitalizing on more profitable opportunities.
Furthermore, historical averages offer little comfort during market downturns. Bear markets can be brutal, as evidenced by the near 50% plunge of the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) between October 2007 and March 2009. These periods serve as stark reminders of the inherent volatility and risk in stock market investing.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/20231219-vg-CFA-Dow_Jones_Historical_Returns-v3-c9b214d9299646a0a123197966645773.png)
Historical performance chart of the Dow Jones Industrial Average, illustrating market fluctuations over time.
The impact of such downturns is particularly severe on retirement accounts like 401(k)s. During the 2008 financial crisis, individuals aged 56 to 65, nearing retirement, experienced the most significant losses due to their typically higher equity exposure.
The 2008 Financial Crisis and Investor Behavior
The Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) conducted a study on the 2008 crash, estimating that it could take up to five years for 401(k) accounts to recover from the losses, assuming an average 5% annual return. This extended recovery period highlights the devastating impact of market crashes, especially when years of accumulated savings and home equity vanish just as retirement approaches.
This turbulent period underscores the significant role of investor psychology and demographics on stock performance. Market exuberance, driven by greed, can inflate asset prices to unsustainable levels, while fear during downturns can trigger panic selling at market lows. This emotional pendulum often leads to mismatches between investor temperament and investment strategies, with inexperienced individuals drawn to speculative trading in pursuit of quick riches, often without understanding the inherent risks.
The Enduring Power of Buy-and-Hold Investing
The buy-and-hold strategy gained prominence in the 1990s, fueled by the rapid growth of technology stocks. The “four horsemen of tech”—Microsoft (MSFT), Intel Corp. (INTC), Cisco Systems (CSCO), and Dell Computer—powered the internet boom and propelled the Nasdaq to unprecedented heights. These companies were perceived as infallible, leading financial advisors to recommend them as lifetime holdings. However, many investors entered the market late in the bull cycle, and when the dot-com bubble burst, these overvalued stocks plummeted.
Despite such historical examples of market bubbles, the buy-and-hold strategy remains effective, particularly with fundamentally strong and less volatile stocks. It rewards patient investors with substantial long-term returns. For individual investors with a long investment horizon, buy-and-hold is still a highly recommended strategy, as the stock market has historically trended upwards over time.
Long-Term Asset Performance: The Raymond James Study
A comprehensive 2011 study by Raymond James and Associates examined the long-term performance of various asset classes over 84 years (1926-2010). The findings revealed that small-cap stocks delivered an average annual return of 12.1%, while large-cap stocks achieved a still-impressive 9.9% return. Both significantly outperformed government bonds, Treasury bills (T-bills), and inflation, establishing equities as highly advantageous investments for long-term wealth accumulation.
The period from 1980 to 2010 was particularly robust for equities, with average annual returns of 11.4%. Interestingly, real estate investment trust (REIT) equities surpassed even this, boasting 12.3% annual returns, partly driven by the real estate boom fueled by the baby boomer generation. This highlights the importance of strategic stock selection within a buy-and-hold framework, requiring either deep expertise or the guidance of a trustworthy financial advisor.
However, the study also revealed periods of underperformance. Large-cap stocks lagged between 2001 and 2010, generating a meager 1.4% annual return, while small-cap stocks maintained their lead with a 9.6% return. These results emphasize the critical need for internal asset class diversification, necessitating a balanced mix of market capitalization and sector exposure within a stock portfolio. Government bonds performed exceptionally well during this same period, but this was likely influenced by the massive “flight to safety” during the 2008 economic crisis.
The Raymond James study further underscored the importance of portfolio diversification, noting that risk increases significantly when investors fail to diversify across capitalization levels, growth versus value styles, and major market benchmarks like the Standard & Poor’s (S&P) 500 Index.
Optimal portfolio balance is often achieved through cross-asset diversification, combining stocks with other asset classes like bonds. This strategy becomes particularly advantageous during equity bear markets, mitigating downside risk.
Risk and Return: Essential Considerations for Stock Market Profitability
While making money in the stock market is achievable, preserving those gains can be challenging. Sophisticated trading algorithms and institutional trading activities contribute to market volatility and reversals, often exploiting herd behavior among retail investors. This dynamic emphasizes the importance of focusing on long-term annual returns. Investing in stocks only makes sense if they offer superior returns compared to other asset classes, such as real estate or money market accounts.
While historical data suggests that equities can deliver stronger returns than other investments, achieving sustained profitability requires robust risk management strategies and disciplined adherence to a well-defined investment plan to avoid common pitfalls and market outliers.
Modern Portfolio Theory and Risk Management
Modern portfolio theory (MPT) provides a foundational framework for understanding risk perception and wealth management, applicable to both novice and experienced investors. Diversification is central to MPT, highlighting that relying on a single asset class carries significantly higher risk compared to a diversified portfolio encompassing stocks, bonds, commodities, real estate, and other security types.
It’s crucial to distinguish between two types of investment risk: systematic and unsystematic. Systematic risk, stemming from macroeconomic events like wars, recessions, and black swan events (unpredictable events with severe consequences), can create high correlation across diverse asset classes, diminishing the benefits of diversification.
Managing Unsystematic Risk
Unsystematic risk refers to the risks associated with individual companies, such as failing to meet earnings expectations or being negatively impacted by industry-specific events. A notable example is the Chipotle Mexican Grill stock decline following a food poisoning outbreak, causing a significant price drop between 2015 and 2017.
To mitigate unsystematic risk, many investors and advisors utilize exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or mutual funds instead of investing in individual stocks. Index investing is a popular approach, limiting exposure to broad market benchmarks like the S&P 500, Russell 2000, and Nasdaq 100.
Index funds, whether structured as ETFs or mutual funds, replicate the holdings of specific market indexes. Both typically feature low expense ratios compared to actively managed funds, with ETFs generally offering even lower fees.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/ExpenseRatios_Final-08e92a1b640245d095884402db1b1882.png)
Comparison chart illustrating typical expense ratios for ETFs versus mutual funds.
However, even diversification through ETFs or mutual funds does not entirely eliminate unsystematic risk. Seemingly unrelated events can exhibit high correlation based on market capitalization or sector, triggering widespread market shocks. Furthermore, cross-market and asset class arbitrage, facilitated by high-speed algorithms, can amplify these correlations and introduce illogical price movements.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Investing in Stocks
The 2011 Raymond James study also highlighted the underperformance of individual investors compared to market benchmarks. Between 1988 and 2008, the S&P 500 index achieved an 8.4% annual return, while individual investors averaged a meager 1.9%.
This significant underperformance can be attributed to several common investor mistakes:
1. Lack of Diversification: As emphasized earlier, a well-diversified portfolio, either built independently or with the help of a skilled investment advisor, is crucial. Diversification across asset classes and equity sub-classes helps to mitigate risk. While exceptional stock pickers may outperform through concentrated bets, sustained outperformance requires significant research, market monitoring, and active portfolio management, which is difficult to maintain consistently over long periods. For most investors, strategic asset allocation offers a more reliable path to long-term success.
However, for smaller investment and retirement accounts focused on initial growth, targeted equity exposure can be beneficial. In these cases, maximizing returns may take precedence over extensive diversification in the early stages, while consistent contributions and employer matching in retirement accounts build the foundational capital.
2. Market Timing: Excessive focus solely on equities can be risky, and investors often compound this risk by attempting to time the market—buying low and selling high.
Professional market timers dedicate years to honing their skills, meticulously analyzing market data, and identifying recurring patterns to develop profitable entry and exit strategies. They understand market cycles and how to capitalize on investor sentiment shifts driven by greed and fear. This contrasts sharply with casual investors whose attempts at market timing often backfire, eroding long-term returns and undermining investor confidence.
3. Emotional Bias: Investors frequently develop emotional attachments to their investments, leading to over-concentration in certain stocks and a blindness to negative signals. While the success stories of companies like Apple and Amazon are compelling, such exceptional performers are rare.
A disciplined, business-like approach to stock ownership is essential, rather than speculative “gunslinger” mentality. The internet often amplifies hype around “the next big thing,” leading investors to chase trends and invest in undeserving stocks based on emotion rather than fundamental analysis.
Trading vs. Investing: Understanding the Difference
Employer-sponsored retirement plans, such as 401(k)s, inherently promote a long-term buy-and-hold investing model, with asset allocation rebalancing typically occurring annually. This structure discourages impulsive trading decisions and fosters a long-term perspective. As investment portfolios grow and financial situations evolve, investors often gain access to self-directed brokerage accounts, rollover individual retirement accounts (IRAs), or engage financial advisors for active asset management.
However, increased investment capital can tempt some investors into the allure of short-term speculative trading, drawn by narratives of successful day traders profiting from short-term price fluctuations. In reality, these high-frequency trading methods are more likely to result in losses than substantial gains for most individuals.
Profitable day trading, similar to successful market timing, demands a full-time commitment and specialized skills, often unattainable for individuals employed outside the financial industry. Professionals within the financial industry approach trading with the precision and discipline of a surgeon, meticulously tracking every dollar and its response to market forces. They understand the significant risks involved and have learned to navigate sophisticated trading algorithms while filtering out unreliable market tips.
Day Trading: Empirical Evidence and Investor Behavior
A 2000 study published in The Journal of Finance from the University of California, Davis, examined common misconceptions about active stock trading. Analyzing data from over 60,000 households, the study found that active trading generated an average annual return of 11.4% between 1991 and 1996—significantly lower than the 17.9% returns of major market benchmarks during the same period. The study also revealed an inverse correlation between trading frequency and investment returns.
The research further indicated that a preference for small, high-beta stocks, combined with overconfidence, typically led to underperformance and higher trading activity. This supports the notion that speculative traders often overestimate their ability to profit from short-term market movements. This approach contrasts with a long-term investment strategy focused on understanding underlying market trends to make informed investment decisions.
A 2015 study by Xiaohui Gao and Tse-Chun Lin provided intriguing evidence suggesting that individual investors perceive trading and gambling as similar activities. They observed an inverse relationship between trading volume on the Taiwan Stock Exchange and the size of the national lottery jackpot. This aligns with the idea that short-term trading can be driven by the adrenaline rush and the prospect of quick gains, similar to gambling.
Interestingly, even losses in speculative trading can generate a sense of excitement, potentially leading to self-destructive behavior as investors “double down” on losing positions in hopes of recouping losses, a strategy that rarely succeeds.
The Intersection of Finances, Lifestyle, and Investor Psychology
Successful stock market investing requires aligning investment strategies with personal finances, lifestyle, and psychological factors. Younger investors entering the workforce may have limited investment options within their 401(k) plans, typically focusing on blue-chip companies and fixed income investments for steady long-term growth.
Conversely, individuals nearing retirement, while having accumulated substantial wealth, may have a shorter time horizon for recovering from potential market downturns. Trusted financial advisors can offer tailored, more actively managed strategies for these investors. Other individuals may prefer to manage their growing nest eggs through self-directed investment accounts.
Self-directed investment retirement accounts (IRAs) offer expanded investment options, including assets like precious metals, real estate, and cryptocurrencies, which are typically restricted in traditional IRAs. However, these accounts require specialized custodians and may not be offered by mainstream brokerages or financial firms.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/Self-Directed_IRA_Final-a0a259329922457cb7379036974f679c.png)
Visual representation of diverse investment options available within a self-directed IRA.
Younger, less experienced investors may inadvertently hinder their progress by experimenting with too many investment approaches without mastering any. Similarly, older investors choosing self-directed investing may make costly errors. Experienced investment professionals generally possess the expertise and discipline to navigate market complexities and optimize portfolio growth.
Addressing personal health and psychological factors is crucial before engaging in active investing. Market behavior often mirrors real-life psychology. Individuals with low self-esteem or unhealthy habits may be drawn to risky, short-term trading, subconsciously believing they are undeserving of long-term financial success. Engaging in high-risk trading with low odds of success may be a manifestation of self-sabotage.
The Ostrich Effect and Investor Behavior During Downturns
A 2006 study in the Journal of Business introduced the “ostrich effect,” describing investors’ tendency to selectively monitor their portfolios, checking them more frequently during market uptrends and less often (or “burying their heads in the sand”) during downturns.
This behavior significantly impacts trading volume and market liquidity. Trading volumes tend to increase in rising markets and decrease in falling markets, reinforcing the tendency for investors to chase uptrends and ignore downtrends. Overconfidence can further exacerbate this, as investors may increase exposure during rising markets, confirming their pre-existing positive bias.
The decline in market liquidity during downturns is consistent with the “ostrich effect,” suggesting that investors avoid monitoring their portfolios during losses to avoid confronting painful realities. This counterproductive behavior extends to risk management, explaining why investors often sell winning stocks too early while holding onto losing stocks for too long—the opposite of what is required for long-term profitability.
Navigating Panic-Inducing Market Situations
Wall Street often emphasizes statistics highlighting the long-term benefits of stock ownership, easily demonstrated by long-term Dow Jones Industrial Average charts, particularly on logarithmic scales that visually minimize the impact of major market crashes.
However, the 84-year period examined in the Raymond James study included at least three significant market crashes, providing a more realistic perspective than selectively chosen industry data.
Alarmingly, three major bear markets have occurred within the last 31 years, well within the investment horizon of many baby boomers. Between these major collapses, stock markets have experienced numerous mini-crashes, sharp declines, and market meltdowns, testing the resolve of even seasoned stock investors.
While it’s easy to dismiss these sharp declines as temporary blips in the long-term upward trend, the psychological biases discussed earlier often come into play during market downturns. Many rational investors panic and liquidate long-term holdings during sell-offs to stop the pain of watching their savings diminish.
Ironically, market downturns often end when enough investors capitulate, creating bottom fishing opportunities for those with the financial capacity and psychological fortitude to buy when prices are low, or for short-sellers to profit from the decline.
Black Swan Events and Unpredictable Market Shocks
Nassim Taleb popularized the concept of a black swan event—an unpredictable event with severe consequences that lies outside normal expectations—in his 2010 book, The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable. He defines three key attributes of a black swan:
- Rarity: It is an outlier, outside the realm of normal expectations.
- Extreme Impact: It has a significant and often devastating impact.
- Retrospective Predictability: Human nature leads to rationalization after the event, making it seem explainable and predictable in hindsight.
Given this third characteristic, it’s understandable why Wall Street rarely emphasizes the negative impact of black swan events on stock portfolios.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/BlackSwan_Final-a023811e4f904e8e8b20a3a285b03d64.png)
Conceptual image representing a black swan event as an unexpected and impactful occurrence.
The term “black swan” itself originates from the historical belief that all swans were white, until black swans were discovered in Australia in 1697, shattering that assumption. Now, “black swan” signifies an unforeseen or seemingly impossible event that unexpectedly becomes reality.
Shareholders need to prepare for black swan events during normal market conditions, mentally rehearsing their response plans. This is akin to a fire drill, familiarizing oneself with exit strategies in case of emergency. Investors must also realistically assess their pain tolerance, as even the best-laid plans are useless if abandoned during the next market downturn.
While financial institutions advocate for staying invested during turbulent times, ultimately, each investor must make their own decisions regarding their portfolio and risk tolerance.
How Beginners Can Start Making Money in the Stock Market
For beginners looking to earn money in the stock market, several key principles can pave the way for success:
1. Start Investing Early: The power of compounding is transformative. Even small initial investments can grow substantially over time as earnings generate further earnings.
2. Adopt a Long-Term Perspective: The stock market is inherently volatile in the short term, but historically, it has consistently appreciated in value over the long term. A long-term investment horizon smooths out short-term market fluctuations.
3. Invest Regularly and Consistently: Disciplined, regular investing is crucial. Take advantage of employer-sponsored 401(k) plans, which automatically deduct and invest a portion of your paycheck. Consider dollar-cost averaging, investing fixed amounts at regular intervals, regardless of market prices.
4. Leverage Professional Expertise: Don’t attempt to pick individual stocks without sufficient knowledge. Financial professionals in mutual funds, ETFs, and other managed funds possess the expertise and resources to manage investments effectively. Investing in these funds also provides instant diversification, reducing risk.
Realistic Expectations for Stock Market Returns
Yes, it’s possible to make significant money in stocks, but realistic expectations are essential. While stories of stocks doubling or tripling in value exist, these are rare occurrences, often associated with day trading or initial public offerings (IPOs).
For typical individual investors, focusing on average stock market returns over time provides a more realistic benchmark. For example, as of December 2023, the S&P 500 Index (SPX), a key indicator of the U.S. stock market, has delivered an average annual return of approximately 13.72% over the past five years and 10.17% over the past 10 years. Since 1990, the S&P 500’s value has increased more than fourteen-fold.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/20231219-vg-CFA-SP500_Historical_Returns-v3-7b5b7840f4494874a4a5701169e29d26.png)
Historical performance chart of the S&P 500 Index, demonstrating long-term growth trends.
Three Core Strategies to Profit from the Stock Market
There are primarily three ways to make money in the stock market:
1. Capital Appreciation (Buy Low, Sell High): This classic strategy involves selling stock shares at a higher price than the purchase price.
2. Short Selling (Sell High, Buy Low): Short selling is essentially the reverse of the traditional approach. It involves borrowing shares (usually from a broker), selling them, and then buying them back later at a lower price to return to the lender, profiting from the price decline. Short selling is a bet that a stock’s price will decrease.
3. Dividend Income: Many established companies distribute a portion of their profits to shareholders in the form of dividends. Dividends are typically paid quarterly and provide a regular income stream for investors, often in cash but sometimes in additional shares.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/DividendPayout_Final-f1a0d92826d44484b8f4e0a3a485198a.png)
Visual representation of dividend payouts to shareholders.
When to Take Profits from Your Stock Investments
Ultimately, the goal of stock investing is to generate profit. However, knowing when to take profit and secure gains is crucial and depends on individual risk tolerance and investment time horizons.
A common pitfall is greed. Some financial professionals recommend taking profits after a stock price has increased by 20% to 25%, even if it appears to be continuing to rise. As William O’Neil, founder of Investor’s Business Daily, famously said, “The secret is to hop off the elevator on one of the floors on the way up and not ride it back down again.”
Other advisors advocate for more nuanced strategies, such as gradual profit-taking. Jeffrey Hirsch, chief market strategist at Probabilities Fund Management, suggests an “up 40%, sell 20%” strategy. This involves selling 20% of a position when a stock price increases by 40%, and then selling another 20% if it rises another 40%, and so on.
The Bottom Line: Building Long-Term Wealth in the Stock Market
Earning money in the stock market and achieving long-term financial prosperity is attainable, but investors must navigate economic, market, and psychological challenges. The most sustainable path to profitability typically begins with choosing the right stockbroker and adopting a focused, wealth-building approach, gradually expanding into new investment opportunities as capital grows.
Buy-and-hold investing remains the most reliable strategy for the majority of investors. While some individuals may develop specialized skills to pursue more active strategies like short-term trading and short selling for potentially higher returns, these approaches carry significantly greater risk and complexity.
